I have a soft spot for books
that go down easy. It's one thing to write literature. It's another
thing to write a book that is, moment-to-moment, pleasurable to read. And I Am Charlotte Simmons went down oh-so-smooth.
But let's
not confuse pleasurable with pleasant: Tom Wolfe is never that. I am
Charlotte Simmons is a rude, mildly-to-moderately misogynistic, 99.5% cynical
indictment of the moral lassitude of today's college darlings, and it is
a billion pages long to boot. Over the course of those pages
Charlotte, the eponymous college freshman, arrives from the backwoods of
Sparta, NC, to live the life of the mind at the famous Dupont
University.
Once at Dupont, Charlotte, obsesses about her image,
falls into and out of various social groups, and "gets the dust knocked
off her" in the cruelest of ways at a fraternity formal. Charlotte is
not particularly likeable, but it's still uncomfortable to watch her go
through Wolfe's wringer and come out: not bowed or broken, but both.
It's
a jam-packed 600+ pages. And yet, in the end, it's hard to intuit
Wolfe's thesis. He makes some rhetorical stabs in the direction of "we
are corrupted by our environment;" but if this was the thrust of the
book, why not make Charlotte's pre-collegiate self more sympathetic?
Pre-Dupont Charlotte, preoccupied by status and cool, doesn't seem so far-removed from the canny coed Charlotte becomes.
And for
all its crudity- and that crudity is creative, voluminous, almost magical in its inventiveness- the book has a curiously puritanical underbelly. Charlotte sins, and she is punished. As are her friends -punished- by themselves,
by their compatriots, or through sheer authorial mischief.
While the ax is getting around to falling, though, it's some party.
Wednesday, January 23, 2013
Tuesday, January 15, 2013
Wednesday, January 2, 2013
Sideber Sidebar
I've decided to retire my gratitude sidebar. It was fun while it lasted. That's a misstatement: it wasn't fun, not exactly, but it was fun's first cousin once-removed, and I figure that's good enough. And heck, sometimes it even brushed up against joy.
But even gratitude -surely among the most grateful of guests- eventually wears out its welcome. Log-term gratitude makes me nervous. I have to follow it around, make sure it has enough towels. It brings lovely hostess gifts, but there's something too snug, too smug, in the crook of its smile.
This doesn't mean that we're estranged, gratitude and I. It just means I'm taking a...recess. Yeah! I had a sidebar, and now we're in recess! (If only I could take a recess from constructing tottering towers of metaphor, though!)
I'll still be grateful. But casually so. Like: oh, hey, right, it's you.
But even gratitude -surely among the most grateful of guests- eventually wears out its welcome. Log-term gratitude makes me nervous. I have to follow it around, make sure it has enough towels. It brings lovely hostess gifts, but there's something too snug, too smug, in the crook of its smile.
This doesn't mean that we're estranged, gratitude and I. It just means I'm taking a...recess. Yeah! I had a sidebar, and now we're in recess! (If only I could take a recess from constructing tottering towers of metaphor, though!)
I'll still be grateful. But casually so. Like: oh, hey, right, it's you.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)